We’ve talked about model railroad scales, we’ve talked about eras, and we’ve talked about scenery styles. But one crucial question we haven’t yet explored is what type of layout will work best for you? In this article, we”ll explore the pros and cons of three major model railroad designs.
The Classic Tabletop Loop
Ah, the loop; the backbone of model railroad design for generations! From the very earliest toy train sets to some of the greatest layouts found today, the loop is a common theme for its flexibility and endless enjoyment. A loop can be as basic as a single circle of track or it can be as complex as a multi-tiered layout with yards, industries, and branches.
Pro: Flexibility of Operation
One of the biggest attractions of loop layouts is the ability to run a train for an endless amount of time regardless of the space you have available. How long is the journey between stations? You decide! It could be a literal trip around the layout, or it could be multiple circuits. Often, modelers will develop a plan for how many times a train will circle their layout between certain stops to signify varying distances.
Pro: A Great Starter Option
Most starter sets come with a single loop of track to allow you to easily get up and running with your new train. If you’re new to the hobby, a loop layout will allow you to build on the very track that comes with your first set. You can use this as a base for your layout plan, and can watch your railroad grow by adding switches, sidings, industries, and perhaps even another loop?
Pro: You Can Sit Back and Relax
Something to consider when planning a layout is what your end goal is. Are you building a model railroad so you can actively operate trains, switch cars, and run schedules? Or would you rather just be able to sit back and watch the trains roll by? If your answer is the latter, a loop is definitely for you! Once you’ve got your loop layout up and running, just grab some popcorn, get the trains rolling and take a step back to admire your handy work!
Con: Design Limitations
With a tabletop loop, you are constrained by having to fit the bulk of your scenery into the center of your layout while the track remains at the edge. While there are plenty of options for what you can do with this space to make it your own, the appearance of the scene will always be dominated by the track bordering the edges, and fully immersing your trains into the scene can be a challenge.
Con: Hard to Expand
While expansion of a tabletop loop layout is certainly possible, it’s not quite as simple as with other designs, as this style is often most effective when it’s self contained.
The “Around the Wall” Loop
This option is sort of the opposite of the classic tabletop. Whereas the layout is the centerpiece to the room with a tabletop design, with an “around the wall” layout, the center is left open, and the layout instead surrounds you. This is a common design used by serious modelers as it encompasses elements of both the classic loop and the shelf layout.
Pro: The Best of Both Worlds
Building a layout around the wall allows you to keep the flexibility of a loop layout (allowing you to run trains continuously) while it also enables you to add prototypical railroad elements and immersive scenery typical of shelf-style layouts.
Pro: 360 Degree Access
If your railroad is your happy place, what better than to be totally surrounded by it when operating it? Entering a room with an “around the wall” layout instantly immerses you in the scene and puts everything within easy reach (depending on the size of the room). You can also view all areas of the layout without being blocked by any scenery in the middle.
Pro: Room for Expansion
While building a leg onto a tabletop style layout might make for an awkward centerpiece for your room (though it can be done!), you can easily add peninsulas to an “around the wall” layout to expand your scene or lengthen the route your train takes around the room. If you don’t have enough space to fit your entire scene, you can even build upwards and add a second level above your original scene by using a helix.
Con: Access to the Room
Unless you’re building your layout in a basement or attic with a centrally placed staircase, you will likely have to negotiate your layout somehow to enter the room. This can be done by adding a thinner “duck-under” section, or by creating a lift bridge or scenery segment on hinges. Either of these options will by nature cause a break in your scenery, or will require more complicated wiring and construction.
Con: Use of Space
Layouts built around the wall will dominate any room they are in. There’s no getting around this. If you want your train room to remain a multi-purpose space, this type of layout might not be the best fit for you.
The End-to-End or Shelf Layout
Shelf layouts are typically built by modelers who want to emulate a real-life location or create a believable scene for true-to-life style railroad operations. They are also built by those who enjoy the challenge and puzzle of prototypical switching operations.
Pro: Use of Space
Shelf layouts can fit into just about any space! They can run the length of a room, along two or more walls, or they can simply fit into a bookcase. These are a great option if you don’t have the space for a larger continuous loop, or if you want to make sure that the layout room can still be used for other purposes.
Pro: Time for Detail
Having a smaller space to work with will challenge you in different ways. With a large layout, you might feel overwhelmed with the amount of work that needs to be done. With a smaller shelf-style layout, you can take more time with each scene to add detail and interest.
Pro: Realistic Operation
While there’s no doubt that a loop style layout will be endless fun, having a layout with set origin and destination points will enhance the believability of your scene and add to the realism of your operations.
Con: Limited Continuous Movement
If you want to be able to sit back and watch the trains run, this layout type probably isn’t for you. Even a larger end-to-end layout will likely only yield a couple of minutes in travel time between destinations, and you have to make sure you’re on hand to stop the train when it reaches the end of the line!
Con: Train Length is a Factor
As mentioned above, one of the great things about a loop layout is the ability to run long trains continuously. With a shelf layout, you’ll need to make sure that your trains are short enough to be able to travel through the scene. A 60 car coal drag probably won’t have much room for movement, so these types of layouts are best suited to replicating short lines and industrial spurs rather than mainline operations.
What Layout is Right for You?
What type of layout do you want to build? Let us know in the comments on Facebook if you’ve built one of the three types listed! We’d love to know what you think of yours!
Get started on your model railroading journey today at modeltrainstuff.com